Fatty's Fish Shack
If you're craving fresh seafood in a relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere, Fatty's Fish Shack in Palm Harbor is the place to be. Located at 1026 Nebraska Ave, this cozy gem offers a delightful dining experience with a fun and welcoming vibe. Whether you're a local or just visiting, it’s the perfect spot to unwind with delicious food, a cold drink, and great company.
The restaurant’s menu is a seafood lover’s dream, with standout dishes that will leave you coming back for more. Don’t miss out on their famous Lump Crab Cake Sandwich, a crowd favorite packed with rich, flavorful crab. If you’re in the mood for something crispy, the Calamari is perfectly fried and paired with a zesty dipping sauce that enhances every bite. Another must-try is the Island Coconut Shrimp, where tropical flavors meet the perfect crunch. And if you're not feeling seafood, their Bison Burger is a juicy alternative, offering a unique twist on a classic. Of course, you can't go wrong with a hearty Grouper Sandwich, which showcases the best of Florida's local catches.
One of the things that sets Fatty's Fish Shack apart is the vibrant yet relaxed atmosphere. The restaurant is perfect for families, with plenty of space and a moderate noise level that ensures a lively, but not overwhelming, dining experience. There’s even outdoor seating for those who want to enjoy their meal in the Florida sunshine. Plus, if you're out with your furry friend, you're in luck—dogs are welcome to join you on the patio.
The restaurant also offers happy hour specials, making it an ideal spot for after-work drinks or a casual evening out. Whether you're coming for the food, the fun, or just to kick back and relax, Fatty's Fish Shack has something for everyone.
Reviews
We had the Smoked Salmon appetizer and I had the Mahi sandwich. Both were delicious. We've been here a lot and they often have excellent music. Parking is pretty easy in this neighborhood as well. There's a lot of typical bar food on the menu but I would appreciate a better salad selection and more info on brews they serve.
Visiting from out of town and decided to give Fatty's a try. Clam chowder and cod sandwich were both nice and hot and very good. If I am ever back in the area I will be stopping in again.
Great happy hour and service. Nice spot to get some appetizers and listen to live music. We had the oysters, fish dip, fried clam strips, pretzel and the cocktails shrimp and a few drinks. All were good, especially for the HH price.
Cool vibe. They have seats inside and out with the outside covered and ample fans to keep it cool. We decided to try on a Tuesday afternoon and the service was quick with the food coming out hot and fresh. We tried the grouper nuggets and the chicken quesadillas. Good bar type food not super but not bad. Will try again and maybe we won't be so hungry that we can take a pic of the food.
My husband and I had never been to Fatty's so we checked them out for happy hour. We were pleasantly surprised by the overall experience. We had the cheeseburger, fried clam strips, and cocktail shrimp off the happy hour menu. The burger was one of the best we've had in the area! For $5, it's a simple burger with cheese; no lettuce, tomato, etc., but it was cooked perfectly with a lovely grilled bun. The shrimp were large and juicy and the clam strips fried nicely golden; not too brown. Service was attentive given there was initially only one on deck and my happy hour margarita was tasty. The atmosphere is rustic and key west-like. We will definitely be back to sample some full dinner items!